Direct Mail Marketing vs Mail2Mobile for Lower CPA
Background
For Eyes optical shops and Upswell had been working together for several years. We’d been constantly testing, learning, revising and advancing. But one area was not improving as much as we wanted: Cost Per Acquisition (CPA).
The client wanted to get the CPA below $50. They were willing to expand both their budget and their marketing mix to achieve that. Our dedicated account manager on For Eyes recommended adding a new mobile marketing tool to the already successful postcard marketing program.
Solution
We put together a six-week-long Mail2Mobile program, a new approach that combines direct mail with mobile marketing. It gave us the power to deliver digital ads to the mobile devices of precisely-targeted prospects immediately before and after the direct mailers hit home. And by optimizing all creative units with consistent, eye-catching design, the messaging was as powerful as it was inescapable.
We also conducted an A/B test. The lists for 50 For Eyes locations got mobile ads plus direct mail. The other 50 stores got only the direct mail marketing. The Mail2Mobile group saw a dramatic drop in CPA and a corresponding rise in response rates.
The Results
While both groups are still performing well, the Mail2Mobile stores are currently associated with a 12% reduction in CPA. Also, their response rates are up 30%.
Mail2Mobile Cost Per Acquisition (CPA)
Direct Mail Cost Per Acquisition (CPA)
%
Mail2Mobile Response Rate
%
Direct Mail Response Rate
See Other Small Businesses We've Helped:
Franchisee Finds a Valuable Lift From Email Prospecting
A franchisee owner of multiple Meineke centers needed a quick turnaround solution for increasing car counts to offset a drop in Paid Search traffic…
Using Social Media to Create a Lead Conversion Funnel
When BODYBAR Pilates came to UpSwell, they were looking to grow their membership for their studio in East Wichita, Kansas. They had tried...
Driving 2,000 New Memberships in Only 6 Weeks
Crunch Fitness started as one gym in New York’s Greenwich Village, and had some 25 locations when it turned to UpSwell for direct mail expertise. Since then…
$240K Annual Revenue Increase with Digital Booster 2.0
An independently owned and operated Christian Brothers Automotive center had been a long time client of UpSwell Marketing. They had seen great success...
How to Double Your Business with Automotive Direct Mail
Anderson Automotive had a good repair shop business built on a reputation for excellent service. As satisfied customers recommended it to friends, Anderson...
Direct mail Creates a Surge of New Member Sign-Ups
Stretch Zone Lincoln Heights had utilized direct mail marketing in the past and received HUGE response, but when the pandemic hit in 2020, they paused…
356% ROI with Digital Booster 2.0
TFG Automotive is an auto repair shop serving Middle Tennessee. Their focus is being a dealership alternative for all automotive needs. They offer dealership level service, mechanics...
Grand Opening Sees Grand Results with Targeted Direct Mail!
The Dog Stop is an all-inclusive dog care facility and pet retail store with over 20 franchise locations across 10 states. Their facilities offer dog daycare…
Why Direct Mail Still Works for Fitness Marketing
Hockessin Athletic Club (HAC) had worked with the same health club marketing company for years. Then they started to see a real dip in their direct…
Using Social Media to Presell Fitness Club Memberships
When Gold’s Gym came to UpSwell, they were just about to open a big new gym in Ocala, Florida. But they didn’t want to spend big on preselling memberships…
Direct Mail Marketing vs Mail2Mobile for Lower CPA
For Eyes optical shops and Upswell had been working together for several years. We’d been constantly testing, learning, revising and advancing. But one…
20:1 ROI with Postcard Marketing via Data-Driven Targeting
Burt Brothers Tire and Auto Repair is a leader in northern Utah. It has 12 locations. It’s one of Bridgestone’s top dealers. And it has no intention to quit growing…